With April 15th less than a month away, taxes are on the minds of many. Take a look at the chart below. It may surprise you.
The chart was created by the Tax Foundation (These are the folks who, annually, tell us when the average American family has finally paid all its taxes - currently, it’s mid April.) with data provided from 2008 IRS tax filings.
The chart shows a record number of people with no tax obligation. With more people now riding in the wagon, who should be pulling it? And how much?
It’s a real concern to me - and it should be for all Americans. To exit the Great Recession we find ourselves in, we need to recreate the conditions for a vibrant, opportunity-filled economy. Taxes, while necessary, are a drag on that economic environment, as they create disincentives to work hard or to risk capital. Increasingly, I hear progressive politicans invoke the mantra of only wanting “to get the rich to pay their fair share?”
But what, pray tell, is ”the rich’s fair share”? Especially if a third of all taxpayers now pay nothing. The so-called rich, a very small number of taxpayers — the 10% of the country that makes more than $92,400 a year — currently pay 72.4% of the nation’s income taxes (With the top 1% paying about 25% of all taxes). With coming changes in the tax law as a result of the expiration of the so-called Bush tax cuts and punitive tax increases coming to “the rich” from new healthcare legislation, that lucky 10% will pay a still greater percentage of the total taxes paid by all citizens up ahead. Yet these are the very people who create jobs, who endow colleges and universities, who fund improvements to communities, and take risks that help us all. To burden them - or at times, demonize them - more and more will NOT be helpful to our economy and our country.
Of course, from time to time, there are probably sound reasons why some people will not have a tax liability. But when 142 million tax returns filed in 2008 resulted in no taxes owed 37% of all filers, we are well on our way to a BIG problem.
These aren’t people who have overpaid their taxes, mind you, or have had so much withheld from their paychecks that they’ll get refunds. No, those people aren’t counted in the totals I’m referring to. Those getting refunds paid taxes and have, as well, provided the government with a zero interest loan. No, my comments here are describing a large and growing group of people who pay no taxes at all.
There’s been a 59% increase in the number of nonpayers since 2000, growing from 32.6 million in 2000 to 51.6 million in 2008. Whle, during the same period, the total tax filers grew by only 10%.
According to the Tax Foundation, “The major elements of the Economic Stimulus Act of 2008 boosted the maximum income for nonpayers to more than $56,700″ — the highest ever.
Government keeps expanding the benefits it promises - healthcare now - and thinks there is a limitless claim on “the rich” to pick up the check of these benefits for everyone. What makes this more laughable is that the administration claims it is cutting taxes for most Americans, when nearly 40% pay no taxes to begin with.
The tax code was originally intended to raise sufficient revenues to pay for the essential services of government. But the tax collection process has morphed into a tool for social engineering that incentivizes or punishes certain behavior to redistribute wealth.
Having fewer and fewer people pay more and more taxes for more benefits for many who pay nothing is a dangerous trend, all the more so given the passage last night of the largest unfunded entitlement - healthcare - since Medicare. The increase in the number of people who pay no taxes mirrors the increase in those receiving benefits from the federal government. This creates a powerful bias toward more spending and against keeping tax rates low (to power the economy), since that burden is increasingly being borne by those at the high end of the income scale.
Unfortunately, these are the entrepreneurs, risk takers and small- business people who create most of the jobs. But be assured, these people will not allow any more of their assets to be taxed away from them than they minimally must allow. In time, with advisors, they will find ways to shelter themselves from more taxation and in so doing they will reduce their own productive contributions to the economy at large. In turn, money - taxes - will be raised from more further down the income scale.
But as more and more people get to ride in the wagon, the wagon will tend to break down. No amount of stimulus money extracted from the fewer and fewer who pay taxes will fix the wagon and get it moving again.
Balance needs to be restored. And soon.
