A very successful hedge fund manager now feels that the S&P 500 is going to 1500. If so, that would be an increase of over 40% from about where it is now.
I don’t know that he’s right, but I thought I’d share some perspectives that, I assure you, you will not read about or see elsewhere, because media unfairly favors negativity. You know, in winter, there may be a storm coming, but more people will tune in if the approaching storm can be cast as impending tragedy.
Back to investing, though, are there any good reasons why stocks should rise?
You betcha! First, stocks are cheap, if the financial world is not actually going bust. James Altucher, the hedge fund guy, notes that stocks are trading at 11 times forward earnings (that means, in general, next year’s [that is, “forward”] stock prices are estimated to be 11 times greater than stocks’ earnings). About 15 times is about average. Low interest rates also suggest that a higher multiple might be appropriate. Forward earnings have a long history of being very good predictors of stock prices.
Altucher also notes the extreme pessimism of investors today. Investor sentiment is back at the levels of July, 2009, when the market was just beginning to recover from its worse setback since the Great Depression. A lot of investors who focus on those low earnings multiples feel they are justified because of a likely upcoming economic downturn or perhaps even an economic collapse in Europe or the USA. In past years, these sorts of assertions would have been met with more skepticism. In the current market environment, there is surprising acceptance of extreme negativity.
Altucher actually sees several positives. (I kid you not!) Let me cite a few examples of large, bearish predictions that, so far, at least, have not developed as the doomsayers believed.
Automobiles
It was believed that auto sales would collapse after the Cash for Clunkers program, whatever you or I think of the value of the program. Many believed that sales would be pulled forward from future sale periods with no lasting impact on the overall trend.
What happened? Well, sales have fallen from the highs of the Cash for Clunkers program, but they are, today, up more than 20% from levels before the program came to be. Could the same thing happen after the expiration of government programs for home sales?
Consumer Spending
For many bearish pundits, consumers are “spent up, not pent up.” They have argued that personal consumption expenditures would fall with home prices. They have (inaccurately) argued that consumers are “70% of the economy” and projected a collapse of our national economy because of anticipated, much weaker consumer spending.
But data tell us, today, that consumer spending has exceeded its old highs, even at current unemployment levels. The spending dip was never as great as predicted by the bears and was very temporary.
Europe and the Euro
Beginning in early May of this year, stock markets around the world collapsed under the weight of non-stop coverage of the sovereign debt crisis in Greece and elsewhere in Europe. Very gloomy predictions said that many countries would soon default in Europe and elsewhere. Many of the loudest (but not most accurate) voices predicted that countries would drop out of the European Union, and that the Euro would go to parity with the dollar. People quickly associated the Euro as very risky, and included with it almost anything except bonds.
Today, just two months later, while the European story is certainly not over, the gloom and doom predictions have not come to pass and are not supported by the current data. The Euro has certainly moved lower since May, but it seems to have found a bottom and has rebounded significantly. At one point there were extreme predictions that a small change in the Euro could imply the loss of thousands of points in the Dow. Didn’t happen.
Taxes
Those with a political agenda have emphasized the impending expiration of the Bush tax cuts. The change might actually stimulate a bipartisan approach to our huge deficit problem. But right now, it’s very difficult for any of us to predict policy outcomes when the specific plan is unknown. Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner, just within the few days, showed flexibility might still come from the Obama Administration on capital gains and dividend taxation. His statements evince more market-friendliness from the Obama folks than I might have expected. If the administration is willing to moderate the upcoming severe changes in the treatment of dividends and capital gains, investors might actually become a bit less pessimistic about its handle on financial matters and its posture towards the very people who have the capital to stimulate employment. Stop demonizing them.
Mortgage Rates
Remember how so many, not so long ago, predicted that mortgage rates would spike when the Fed ended its mortgage purchase program? Instead, rates have dropped, reaching record lows. I understand that many excuses can be offered for this failed prediction, but it was a very inaccurate call. The Fed exited gracefully from this market. Once again, it is something to bear in mind as the Fed reduces its involvement in the economy on other fronts over time. The end of the world may not be coming just yet.
There are and will remain many very large and real economic problems. But extreme pessimism, such as we have been hearing of late, is not helpful to investors nor to America. I may be more optimistic than I should be. I can’t predict the future. But I don’t want to part of the problem, either.
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++
To those of you who know me and my family’s story (see www.LettersforLizzie.com), I ask for your prayers for my wife Lizzie. The possibility of renewed, major health problems has arisen. We will be visiting a fleet of specialists this week looking for answers to what ails my dear Lizzie. If you think of us, please pray for us. We hope things come out well. If they do, I’ll be back to this page soon. If they do not, then it will likely take me longer to return. In the meantime, thank you for reading my blog.
Tags: investing, market cycles, pessimism